Instagram collabs have become one of the most effective ways to grow your brand without spending a fortune. But if you’re only chasing big-name influencers, you might be missing the sweet spot. Mid-tier influencers often have stronger engagement, more loyal audiences, and are open to creative partnerships that offer value beyond just money. When done right, these collabs benefit both sides: brands get real traction, and influencers grow their content, credibility, and reach.
Read more about Social Media
This post breaks down how to build Instagram collaborations that deliver results for everyone involved.
How to Craft Instagram Collabs That Reward Both You and Mid-Tier Influencers
1. Find the Right Fit, Not Just a Pretty Feed
Start by identifying influencers who already align with your values or niche. If you sell skincare, look for someone who talks about wellness or routines, not just selfies. If you sell food, go beyond beauty pages and explore lifestyle, parenting, or fitness creators who share meal prep or market hauls. The best collabs feel natural to the audience. They should already be talking about the problems your product solves.
2. Reach Out with a Clear, Respectful Pitch
Your first message should be short, respectful, and personal. Mention what you like about their content. Explain what your brand does in one line, then suggest how you can work together. Avoid generic DMs like “Hi, let’s collab.” Instead, say something like “Your reel on morning routines caught our eye. We’d love to send you a sample of our tea brand and explore a content partnership if you’re open.” Make them feel seen, not targeted.
3. Make the Offer Win-Win
Not all influencers want cash upfront. Some are happy to receive products, long-term partnerships, exposure, or affiliate earnings. Be clear about what you’re offering and flexible with how they prefer to work. Offering creative control often matters more than money. Allow them to present your brand in their own voice. The more it feels like their content, the more their audience will respond.
4. Use Instagram’s Collab Feature to Maximise Reach
Once you’ve agreed on a post or reel, publish it using Instagram’s built-in collab tool. This allows the content to appear on both your feeds with shared likes, comments, and visibility. It also boosts the algorithm’s push. It’s a small step, but it makes the partnership feel real and visible, not like a one-sided promotion.
Sign up for the Connect Nigeria daily newsletter
5. Encourage Real Stories, Not Just Shoutouts
Let influencers create content that feels like a story, not a sales pitch. A skincare creator can share how your product fits into their night routine. A fashion influencer can style your piece with a personal story attached. Audiences are tired of generic “Ad” posts. Real-life context builds trust and keeps engagement high.
6. Measure Engagement, Not Just Follower Count
Mid-tier influencers often have more loyal followers than mega influencers. Look at likes, saves, comments, and shares. Are people asking questions? Are they tagging friends? Do followers trust the influencer’s word? These signals matter more than the size of the account. A smaller creator with deep community ties can move more product than a big name with low engagement.
7. Follow Up and Keep the Door Open
After the post goes live, thank the influencer publicly and privately. Share the post on your stories and tag them. Track performance and share results with them. If it went well, suggest another collaboration. Repeat partnerships build stronger trust and better results over time. Influencers are more likely to put in effort when they know it is not a one-time gig.
Register to attend the CN Business Mixer
Conclusion
Mid-tier influencers are powerful partners when you approach them with respect, value, and creativity. Crafting the right Instagram collabs is not about flashy numbers. It’s about shared goals, smart content, and mutual respect. When both sides win, the audience feels it too, and that’s where real growth happens.
Find our comprehensive listings of businesses in Nigeria here (https://businesses.connectnigeria.com/)
